Immigrant Entrepreneurs: Fueling Innovation and Economic Growth in the US

Yet, in difficult times, they become the scapegoats while living in fear.

Recently, I saw a post from a former colleague asking LinkedIN to help find a new role urgently for another colleague who had been recently laid-off but was also under a work visa. This news hit me hard for 2 reasons.

I had hired this person about 2 years ago and he immediately displayed a set of skills and professionalism which justified plainly why we hired him. Within a couple of weeks, he had identified some areas in our product processes which could be immediately improved. This resulted in better managed release cycles. If anyone wants his info, please reach out to me.

Secondly, I was in his shoes not so long ago. I remember the time when I was laid-off of Motorola in the middle of my Green Card application. The process had started prior to the negative employment cycle, and I was left in a no-man’s land of questions, anguish and fear, wondering what was next for me and my family. Despite having a wife born US citizen, it didn’t mean much when there were still so many pending steps. On top of it, I had now for the first time to justify of my professional expertise in order to remain in the country.

There was also another time, during an immigrant visa adjustment when I was not allowed to leave the country because it would have meant restarting the process to zero. Back in the back of the line. This meant that for 6 months, I was not allowed to see my family back in the Old World and if something bad was to happen, I was stuck in a no-travel mind jail. I remember when someone handed me a sticker with an American flag and the words “America, love it or leave it”. I thought it was kinda neat until I realized what it truly means. I was not welcome as a fresh immigrant with no job prospect. There was no win-win for me, just lose-lose.

So, I thought about all these laid-off workers who like me came to the US to realize their American Dream. Right, now the American Dream for them is this shimmer hope to find a new sponsor for their visa. And the odds are stacked against them.

Yet, while our political parties are ramping up the rhetoric about immigration reform one way or the other, we lost sight of the regular people affected by it. And here, I am talking about legal immigrants who came to America via a work visa due to unique skills and with the capacity to pay for the legal help (or be helped), not immigrants who came here out of desperation trying to stay alive and find a safe refuge. No immigrants should be labelled illegals, just in different status adjustments.

You see, immigration has long been a driving force behind the success and dynamism of the United States. Beyond the cultural richness it brings, immigrants also play a vital role in fostering entrepreneurship and economic growth. Immigrant entrepreneurs, armed with determination, innovation, and diverse perspectives, contribute significantly to the US economy, generating jobs, creating wealth, and propelling technological advancements. Let’s dig into specifics if you are not convinced yet.

1. Job Creation and Economic Growth:

Immigrant entrepreneurs have a proven track record of job creation. According to a study by the National Foundation for American Policy, immigrant-founded billion-dollar companies created an average of approximately 760 jobs per company in the US. Furthermore, these companies collectively generated over $125 billion in sales revenue. Examples such as Elon Musk, the co-founder of PayPal, Tesla and SpaceX, who was born in South Africa, exemplify the immense impact immigrant entrepreneurs have on the economy. Especially when they have some money to start with.

2. Technological Advancements and Innovation:

Immigrant entrepreneurs have been at the forefront of groundbreaking technological advancements in the US. Many immigrants have founded and led pioneering tech companies that have revolutionized industries and propelled innovation. For instance, Sergey Brin, a co-founder of Google, was born in Russia, and Vinod Khosla, co-founder of Sun Microsystems, hails from India. These visionary entrepreneurs have not only brought technological innovations but have also paved the way for countless startups and smaller businesses to thrive. We cannot also forget the large amount of Nobel Prizes in American Universities who are first generation immigrants. Yet, it counts as a US prize.

3. Investment and Capital Influx:

Immigrant entrepreneurs also attract significant investments and capital to the US. The success stories of immigrant entrepreneurs encourage venture capitalists and angel investors to fund promising startups, resulting in a boost to the economy. Additionally, immigrant entrepreneurs often reinvest their profits back into the US, further stimulating economic growth. How many of these immigrant successful entrepreneurs also become investors in American start-ups?

4. Impact of Immigration Policies and Visas:

The impact of immigration policies and visa programs cannot be understated when it comes to the contributions of immigrant entrepreneurs. Policies that facilitate the entry and retention of talented foreign entrepreneurs can create an environment that fosters economic growth and innovation. Initiatives like the H-1B visa and the Entrepreneur Visa can attract skilled foreign entrepreneurs, enabling them to start businesses and contribute to the US economy. Conversely, restrictive immigration policies and visa limitations can discourage talented entrepreneurs from choosing the US as their entrepreneurial destination, potentially causing a drain of talent to other countries. My personal journey through the US immigration was not a walk in the park. As I mentioned prior, there were scary moments of uncertainties, unclarity in my status fillings. I arrived under a J-1, then got 2 H1-Bs, then a Green Card and finally applied for US Citizenships. It was a multi-years investment on the part of my employers and my family but the return for me and them was greater.

By adopting favorable immigration policies and visa programs that attract and retain talented foreign entrepreneurs, the US can harness the full potential of these individuals and ensure a prosperous and vibrant future.

When discussing the impact of immigration policies and visas on immigrant entrepreneurs, it is essential to consider the implications of these policies on individuals who are on work visas, particularly when they face the unfortunate circumstance of being laid off from their jobs like my former team member or myself.

1. Work Visa Limitations: Immigrant entrepreneurs often rely on work visas such as the H-1B visa to establish and operate their businesses in the US. These visas allow skilled foreign workers to work temporarily in the country. However, work visas come with certain limitations and conditions. If an immigrant entrepreneur is laid off or loses their job, their work visa may be tied specifically to that employer, making it challenging to switch jobs or continue operating their business.

2. Uncertainty and Disruption: Losing a job as an immigrant entrepreneur on a work visa can lead to significant uncertainty and disruption. Immigrant entrepreneurs may have invested considerable time, effort, and resources into establishing their businesses in the US. A sudden layoff can disrupt their plans, jeopardizing the future of their ventures and potentially leading to financial strain.

3. Visa Status and Immigration Enforcement: The loss of a job can impact an individual's visa status. Work visas are typically tied to a specific employer, and if the employment relationship ends, it may trigger a change in the individual's legal status. Depending on the circumstances and visa type, they may be required to find new employment quickly, transition to a different visa category, or even leave the country. The process of navigating visa-related changes can be complex and stressful for immigrant entrepreneurs, potentially impeding their ability to contribute to the US economy.

4. Barriers to Entrepreneurship: In some cases, the loss of a job on a work visa may deter immigrant entrepreneurs from pursuing their entrepreneurial aspirations. The challenges and uncertainties associated with transitioning to a different visa category or finding new employment can make it difficult for individuals to maintain the same level of commitment to their business endeavors. Consequently, some talented entrepreneurs may decide to leave the US and explore entrepreneurial opportunities in countries with more favorable immigration policies and support for startups.

The impact of immigration policies and visas on immigrant entrepreneurs goes beyond their initial entry into the US. Policies and visa limitations can significantly affect their ability to sustain their businesses and contribute to the economy, particularly when faced with job loss.

Recognizing the importance of immigrant entrepreneurs and the potential setbacks they may face due to work visa limitations; it is crucial for policymakers to consider ways to provide more flexibility and support for these individuals. Creating pathways for entrepreneurship and facilitating transitions between visas can enable immigrant entrepreneurs to continue their innovative contributions and bolster the US economy in the long run.

My personal journey has been bumpy with job losses, entrepreneurship failures but also with successes beyond my wildest dream. So, when I look at hiring someone, I never care about their immigration status, their origins, their skin colors or their look and gender, I look at their story, I look at their talents, I look at their journey. If they have known hardships along their career, hardships maybe in their life, this means their resiliency in the face of crisis, unknowns and uncertainties is greater than most who have not suffer or anguish to get where they are at. And in a professional setting, this means greater commitment.

Immigrants are a resilient bunch. I hope most will be allowed to remain in the US. I hope we will be able to give laid-off immigrants more than the 30 days or 60 days ticking clock for them to figure out their options and reconstruct their life. Here or somewhere else but we need to give them a chance.

*******************************

Additionally, if you would like to consult some references to laws and legal aspects related to work immigration visas in the United States, here is a snapshot of them in a nutshell:

1. Immigration and Nationality Act (INA): The INA is the primary federal law governing immigration in the United States. It outlines the various categories of visas, including work visas, and establishes the eligibility requirements, procedures, and limitations for each category. The INA can be found in Title 8 of the United States Code.

2. H-1B Visa Program: The H-1B visa program allows employers in the US to hire foreign workers in specialty occupations. The program is governed by regulations set forth by the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) and the Department of Labor (DOL). Information about the H-1B program, including requirements, application processes, and updates, can be found on the USCIS website (www.uscis.gov) and the DOL website (www.dol.gov).

3. L-1 Visa Program: The L-1 visa program allows multinational companies to transfer employees from their foreign branches to their US offices. The program is also administered by USCIS and has specific regulations and requirements. USCIS provides detailed information on the L-1 visa program on their website.

4. EB-5 Immigrant Investor Program: The EB-5 program provides a pathway to permanent residency for foreign investors who make substantial investments in new commercial enterprises that create jobs in the US. The program is administered by USCIS, and information on the requirements and procedures can be found on their website.

5. Department of Labor (DOL) Regulations: The DOL plays a significant role in the employment-based visa process. They oversee the labor certification process, which requires employers to demonstrate that hiring foreign workers will not adversely affect US workers. The DOL website provides information on labor certification and prevailing wage requirements.

It's important to note that immigration laws and regulations are subject to change, so it's advisable to consult the official websites of USCIS, DOL, and other relevant government agencies for the most up-to-date information. Additionally, seeking guidance from immigration attorneys or professionals specializing in immigration law can provide comprehensive and tailored advice regarding work immigration visas.